Connect with us
Advertisement

Judges’ case: Khama speaks out

SEEKING JUSTICE: The case in which four judges of the High Court four suspended judges Key Dingake, Mercy Garekwe, Ranier Busang and Modiri Letsididi want the court to declare invalid their suspension from the bench as well as the decision to appoint a tribunal to investigate them with potential for their removal from judicial office has been postponed to September 28th. President Khama has suspended them for receiving “undeserved accommodation allowances unlawfully”.

President Lt. Gen. Ian Khama has said that he was gravely troubled by the information that the four suspended judges Key Dingake, Mercy Garekwe, Ranier Busang and Modiri Letsididi received undeserved accommodation allowances unlawfully.

Subsequent to suspending the judges, Khama stated in court papers in a judicial marathon case this week that the suspended judges’ alleged misbehavior is that they had been for a considerable amount of time occupied residential accommodation provided for and paid by the government of Botswana whilst at the same time wrongfully receiving a housing allowance from government in lieu of such accommodation.

In the case, the suspended judges want the court to declare invalid their suspension from the bench as well as the decision to appoint a tribunal to investigate them with potential for their removal from judicial office.

A source observing the marathon case on Thursday outside court told Weekend Post that history is not on the suspended Judges’ side. “In African history it shows that if a president appoints a tribunal to investigate judges for misbehavior or whatever they may call it, they did not reappear at the bench,” he said, adding that the said judges are unlikely to come back.

In an answering affidavit filed before court President Khama pointed out that: “I was so gravely troubled by this information as, on the face of it, it implied the possible commission of a serious offence by honourable Judges of the High Court as to be driven to act in order to protect the integrity of the judiciary.”

In addition Khama asserted that he was also informed that following the initiation of the investigation the said judges wrote a letter to the Chief Justice and copied to all other Judges of the High Court and therefore was saddened by the development as well.

“I regard in a very serious light the contents and tone of such letter which, in my view undermines the authority of the Chief Justice of Botswana, and damaging to our judiciary,” he highlighted in the papers.

According to Khama, he is even more concerned about the subsequent letter of the 17th August 2015 which was co-authored by the suspended Judges together with “eight other judges,” which are not applicants in the matter. Although others believe the suspension of the four Judges to be a witch hunt on Justice Dingake as he is seen as a thorn on government side and “anti-government” in his rulings, speculations are rife on the other side that the other judges (eight) may be next on line.

Khama explains why the suspended Judges were not awarded hearing

According to President Khama in his affidavit, he explained that the Judges were not eligible to a hearing pre-suspension. “I did not afford the applicants (suspended Judges) a hearing before their suspension. I have been advised by my attorneys which advise I verily believe to be true that the applicants are not entitled to a pre suspension hearing,” he said.

Khama explained that the suspended judges’ right to be heard has been curtailed as they will be afforded an opportunity to be heard at the tribunal.

President disputes he is interfering in the judiciary

“I deny having any intention of interfering with the composition and functioning of the judiciary as alleged. I therefore deny any suggestion of mala fides on my part,” the President said.

Khama maintains the constitution of Botswana gives him powers

In his affidavit, Khama maintains that he has handled the matter in terms of the power reposed in him by the provisions of the constitution of Botswana and avers that he exercised his discretion judicially.


He stated: “in the circumstances and considering the gravity of this matter I undertook and exercised my discretion in terms of the provisions of the constitution to suspend the four applicants (four Judges) and wrote individual letters to them dated the 26th August 2015 notifying them of my decision as well as the basis thereof.”

Balance of convenience versus preservation of judicial integrity

The fourth president of Botswana has said that he does not take lightly assertions that his decision to suspend judges undermines judicial independence; the right to equal protection before the law and freedom of expression; as well as interfering with the suspended judges’ claimed right to work.


“Further contrary to the assertions of the applicants in their supplementary affidavit, the balance of convenience favours the preservation of the integrity of the judiciary,” he added.

The matter is not urgent – Khama maintains

In his answering affidavit before court, Khama says that he believes that the matter is not urgent. “I wish to emphasize that in the same letter of suspension I disclosed to the Judges that the suspensions will take effect on the 1st September 2015,” Khama highlighted. When suspending them, Khama wrote individual suspension letters to them dated 26th August 2015.


“Thus the applicants (suspended Judges) had sufficient notice not only of the decision to suspend them, but also as to when the said decision will be implemented.” “Consequently I am surprised that the applicants are seeking a stay of events that have already occurred at this hour when they had the opportunity to do so before the 1st September 2015,” he concluded.


Meanwhile the matter will be heard on 28 September before Justice Tebogo Tau who presides over the case as on Thursday he conceded the request to postpone the case by the attorneys of both parties; Attorney General Chambers representing the President as well Chibanda Makgalemele and Company for the suspended Judges.

Continue Reading

News

BDP decides Balopi’s fate

22nd November 2021
Balopi

The Botswana Democratic Party (BDP) Central Committee (CC) meeting, chaired by President Dr Mokgweetsi Masisi late last month, resolved that the party’s next Secretary-General (SG) should be a full-time employee based at Tsholetsa House and not active in politics.

The resolution by the CC, which Masisi proposed, is viewed as a ploy to deflate the incumbent, Mpho Balopi’s political ambitions and send him into political obscurity. The two have not been on good terms since the 2019 elections, and the fallout has been widening despite attempts to reconcile them. In essence, the BDP says that Balopi, who is currently a Member of Parliament, Minister of Employment, Labour Productivity and Skills Development, and a businessman, is overwhelmed by the role.

This content is locked

Login To Unlock The Content!

Continue Reading

News

BDF-Namibians shootings autopsy report revealed

22nd November 2021
BDF

The Botswana Defence Force (BDF)-Namibians fatal shooting tragedy Inquest has revealed through autopsy report that the BDF carried over 800 bullets for the mission, 32 of which were discharged towards the targets, and 19 of which hit the targets.

This would mean that 13 bullets missed the targets-in what would be a 60 percent precision rate for the BDF operation target shooting. The Autopsy report shows that Martin Nchindo was shot with five (4) bullets, Ernst Nchindo five (5) bullets, Tommy Nchindo five (5) bullets and Sinvula Munyeme five (5) bullets. From the seven (7) BDF soldiers that left the BDF camp in two boats, four (4) fired the shots that killed the Namibians.

This content is locked

Login To Unlock The Content!

Continue Reading

News

Gov’t confused over Moitoi’s UN job application

22nd November 2021
VENSON MOITOI

The former Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, Pelonomi Venson-Moitoi’s decision to apply for the positions of United Nations Special Representative of the Secretary-General (SRSG) and their deputies (DSRSG), has left the government confused over whether to lend her support or not, WeekendPost has established.

Moitoi’s application follows the Secretary-General’s launch of the third edition of the Global Call for Heads and Deputy Heads of United Nations Field Missions, which aims to expand the pool of candidates for the positions of SRSG) and their deputies to advance gender parity and geographical diversity at the most senior leadership level in the field. These mission leadership positions are graded at the Under-Secretary-General and Assistant Secretary-General levels.

This content is locked

Login To Unlock The Content!

 

Continue Reading
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!