Motswedi Securities’ has released a thorough assessment of the Botswana Telecommunications Corporation Limited (BTCL) issuing a Long Term Buy recommendation on BTCL at the current price.
The Research team at Motswedi Securities notes that the BTCL growth strategy is centred on leveraging its fixed, mobile and convergent products and services potential. He says the strategy is intended to leverage BTCL’s unique market position as the only fixed and mobile network operator in Botswana by creating competitive advantages for the company through the provision of traditional fixed and mobile broadband, information and content capabilities. It is interesting to note that BTCL is trading at a 35% discount to its NAV. (Current price – P1.47).
“With a PE of 6.8x against the market average of 16.9x and a PBv of 0.8, we still maintain a LONG TERM BUY recommendation on BTCL at the current price.”
WHERE IS THE GROWTH STORY?
According to the report BTCL has copper access network making it the only operator with the capacity to offer ADSL (Asymmetric Digital Subscriber Line Service). ADSL is a data communication service that enables faster data transmission over copper telephone services than convectional voice and modem can provide. BTCL could leverage on this competitive advantage by offering this ADSL product through its copper network, thereby increasing data sales.
Further the Motswedi Securities team notes that the Wider Network footprint and report that BTCL through its BeMobile unit has the widest mobile coverage particularly in remote areas because of its extensive mobile coverage. No other operator has assets deployed as widely across both fixed and mobile services space as BTCL. The mobile network can leverage on this extensive coverage to grow its market share. The researchers also recognize BTCL’s Strong brand recognition and perception, especially in the fixed line business.
The company’s Increased Market Share also speaks to the growth story. According to the report, the BeMobile business is less than 9 years old but already it has gained a notable market share of around 17% which is commendable in this environment dominated by two other giants.
“BTCL is the sole provider of fixed telephony, with this segment being the second driver of revenue, contributing 32%. It is interesting to note that the fixed telephony segment has shown a slight but constant growth over the years in terms of revenue and is expected to continue holding its ground in the short to midterm mainly due to increased usage from the corporate and the government. Having said this, we are equally aware of the decline of this business on a global scale on the long term.”
The Motswedi Securities team is convinced that the BTCL runs a highly profitable business with a strong dividend distribution. It notes that BTCL bounced backed into profitability with all the profitability ratios growing exponentially. The positive numbers are expected to continue going into the future. Further, the researchers point out that Product innovation is expected to continue improving due to the partnership with Vodafone, one of the world’s leading communications services providers. Another plus for BTCL is the fact that the government remains the majority shareholder with a 51% stake in BTCL:
“The government may consider reducing its stake in BTCL to inject both liquidity, innovation and management skills that would better serve the country, investors, the entity and all its stakeholders. This would allow the company the swiftness it needs to remain competitive and profitable. The government can have both control and strategic influence in order to effect social and public policy, while maintaining a minority shareholding, with special voting rights (class A shares). This also promotes better price discovery, improved market liquidity, strategic alliances and partnership, improved competition and a diversified shareholder base and all these will feed positively into BTCL bottom line.”
THE POSSIBLE CHALLENGES
The Motswedi Securities research team has not ignored the possible challenges to the BTCL beautiful story. They acknowledge that BTCL operates in a highly competitive and mature market with intense price competition. Tele density level is above 171% and the only way for BeMobile to expand its market share from the current 17% is to take away subscribers from other networks. This might be a tall order given that the other two giant mobile networks will certainly do anything to protect their territories.
Another factor is the increased competition in the telecoms sector within the country as a result of market liberalisation and this has led in some instances BTCL losing some of its key clients to competitors. The researchers further indicate that Liquid Telecom will also be launching a new telecoms network provider with extensive reach across Botswana soon.
“The business is a high volume business with profitability very sensitive to variation in margins. This is because, BoFinet determines the margins available to network operators and in some cases BTCL may not be able to pass on to the retailer any margin compression enforced by BoFinet and this will eat on margins and profitability,” write in the BTCL assessment report.
Expected decline in Fixed Telephone revenue in the future could also add to the downside of BTCL, they say. According to the Motswedi Securities researchers, the Regulatory risk still remain elevated. BOCRA has started implementing a Pricing Framework which seeks to align to cost, retail prices for mobile voice and mobile broadband.
“Implementation of the Framework has been phased over three years and has already began. The implementation has started with the removal of mobile Termination Rates and differences in prices between the off-net premiums (between networks) and on-net rates. This may impact negatively on revenue from the sector at large and by extension BTCL,” reads the report.
Meanwhile trading of the stock is currently restricted to citizens or wholly owned citizens companies. The Motswedi Securities team argue that this may impact on liquidity and price discovery. Further, they say, the government may consider Market Liberalisation and opening up the market to international investors so as to give BTCL a wider brand exposure and investor base.
STRONG FINANCIAL RESULTS
BTCL FY Financial results for the year ended 31 March 2017 showed a 9% growth in sales driven by growth in fixed, mobile and data sales. Mobile revenues increased by 5% and is the biggest contributor to total revenue at 37%, followed by Fixed Telephony Revenues at 32% and Data services revenue at 29%. “We expect the contribution of Fixed telephony to gradually decline in the future in preference of mobile phones which offers more convenience,” the Motswedi Securities researchers observe.
GP margins improved to 58% from 51%. Total cost were trimmed by 26%, while no impairment were recognised for the year following an impairment assessment exercise carried out at year end. EBITDA grew strongly by 40% to P369mn (FY16: P263mn) with EBITDA margin improving to 23% from 18%. PAT bounced back strongly into the positive territory at P237mn from a loss of P371mn the previous year and this also pushed the net profit margin to 15% from -25%.
“BTCL growth strategy is centred on leveraging its fixed, mobile and convergent products and services potential. The strategy is intended to leverage on BTCL’s unique market position as the only fixed and mobile network operator in Botswana by creating competitive advantages through the provision of traditional fixed and mobile broadband, information and content capabilities. It is interesting to note that BTCL is trading at a 35% discount to its NAV. (Current price – P1.47). With a PE of 6.8x against the market average of 16.9x and a PBv of 0.8, we still maintain a LONG TERM BUY recommendation on BTCL.”
TELECOMMUNICATION MARKET OVERVIEW
The telecommunications market is dominated by the three operators which operate under Public Telecommunications Operator (PTO) licence; namely: BTCL, Mascom and Orange Botswana. The other major player in the market is Botswana Fibre Networks (BoFiNet), which was issued with an interim licence to provide wholesale services beginning 1 April 2013. BoFiNet started offering services in October 2013.
In addition, Private Telecommunications Network Licences (PTNL) have been issued to entities to build private networks for internal business use. Although the PTO licence allows the operators to offer both mobile and fixed telephony services and products, the industry still has 3 players with Mascom and Orange offering mobile telephony services only including mobile Internet and value add services, while BTCL provides both the fixed and mobile telephony services. This includes data network services, providing access and connectivity.
Newly established wholly indigenous citizen owned retail chain Payless Retail (PTY) Ltd is set to partake in the first session of Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE)’s Tshipidi Mentorship Program (TMP) on Monday June 29th.
The TMP aims to train and capacitate SMEs so they can operate as corporates and eventually list on the local bourse. According to local bourse, BSE, the program aims to provide practical training to potential issuers through a comprehensive and interactive program that covers the key themes necessary to position a company to list on the BSE.
Payless Retail is a newly established supermarket chain whose mission is to become a convenient one-stop shopping destination as it is one of the Botswana oldest retailing brands. It started off as Corner Supermarket in January 1976, and to date boasts of nine stores in, among others, Gaborone, Mochudi, Molepolole and Tlokweng. Payless was recently acquired by Ellis Retail Group, which is led by businessman Elliot Moshoke.
The takeover catapulted Ellis Retail to the envious position of being the first wholly indigenous owned major retail chain. “We jumped at this opportunity because it gave us a chance to prove to Batswana that the retail business is open and lucrative.”
The objective is to create a proudly Botswana retail chain that fully supports our national Vision, economic development and citizen economic empowerment ambitions,” Moshoke told BusinessPost.
He further emphasized that Batswana are capable and able to run large scale businesses hence they need to accept invite foreign investors who will come in to support us not take the business. “Our win as Payless in the Fast Moving Consumer goods (FMCG) industry is a win for Batswana. We need their support in this difficult and challenging journey.
As you are aware, Payless is the only retail chain in the hands of Batswana ba Sekei. We need to take advantage of this to generate employment and create small businesses in retail and Agri businesses,” he explained.
The retailer has also partnered with Botswana Investment & Trade Center (BITC) on their #PushaBW campaign with a view to initiating earnest engagement with local producers to iron out bottlenecks and ensure seamless trading.
“Local producers have to be part of the phenomenal growth of the Payless brand. This will in turn facilitate employment creation and economic growth. We did this because we have the utmost respect for local manufacturers and producers,” he mentioned.
Payless is currently restocking all of its stores; a development that Moshoke says is testament to the retailer’s commitment to growing the brand and ensuring continuity of business. He further revealed that renowned retail suppliers like PST and CA Sales have reignited their trust in Payless, opening their doors for Payless as they have faith in the retailer’s new owners.
The takeover has reportedly saved more than 200 jobs and gave a new lease of life to the previously fledging Payless brand. According to a press release from the management team, the Payless work forces are also extremely excited about what the future holds. The TMP is a comprehensive and interactive program that covers the key themes necessary to position a company to list on the BSE.
The program is administered by experts within the listing ecosystem and seeks to bring the potential issuers closer to the listings advisers, investors and leaders of already listed companies. “As a strategic initiative, the BSE decided to set up this mentorship program in a bid to assist SMEs to strategize, corporatize and acclimatize in order to list to access equity finance and expand operations,” said the BSE.
The TMP will avail to SMEs practical insights, knowledge and feedback from institutional investors, increased awareness of the BSE listing requirements as well as an intimate network of advisors and CEOs of listed companies. After training, Payless will graduate with improve governance structures and better knowledge of articulating its business strategy. The retailer will also gain increased visibility through BSE marketing platforms.
Despite Covid-19 interrupting trade worldwide, exporting companies in Botswana which benefited from the Botswana Investment and Trade Centre (BITC) services realised P2.96 billion in export earnings during the period from April 2020 to March 2021.
In the preceding financial year, the sale of locally manufactured products in foreign markets had registered export revenue of P2, 427 billion against a target of P3, 211 billion BITC, which celebrates 10 years since establishment, continues to carry out several initiatives targeted towards expanding the Botswana export base in line with Botswana’s desire to be an export led economy, underpinned by a robust export promotion programme in line with the National Export Strategy.
The main products exported were swamp cruiser boats, pvc tanks and pvc pipes, ignition wiring sets, semi-precious stones, veterinary medicines, hair braids, coal, textiles (towels and t-shirts) and automobile batteries. These goods were destined mainly for South Africa, Zimbabwe, Austria, Germany, and Namibia.
With Covid-19 still a problem, BITC continues to roll out targeted virtual trade promotion missions across the SADC region with a view to seeking long-lasting market opportunities for locally manufactured products.
Recently, the Centre facilitated participation for Botswana companies at the Eastern Cape Development Council (ECDC) Virtual Export Symposium, the Botswana-Zimbabwe Virtual Trade Mission, the Botswana-Zambia Virtual Trade Mission, Botswana-South Africa Virtual Buyer/Seller Mission as well as the Botswana-Namibia Virtual Trade Mission.
BITC has introduced an e-Exporting programme aimed at assisting Botswana exporters to conduct business on several recommended e-commerce platforms. Due to the advent of COVID-19, BITC is currently promoting e-trade among companies through the establishment of e-commerce platforms and is assisting local companies to embrace digitisation by adopting e-commerce platforms to reach export markets as well as assisting local e-commerce platform developers to scale up their online marketplaces.
During the 2019/2020 financial year, BITC embarked on several initiatives targeted at growing exports in the country; facilitation of participation of local companies in international trade platforms in order to enhance export sales of local products and services into external markets.
BITC also helped in capacity development of local companies to compete in global markets and the nurturing of export awareness and culture among local manufacturers in order to enhance their skills and knowledge of export processes; and in development and implementation of trade facilitation tools that look to improve the overall ease of doing business in Botswana.
As part of building export capacity in 2019/20, six (6) companies were selected to initiate a process to be Organic and Fair Trade Certified. These companies are; Blue Pride (Pty) Ltd, Motlopi Beverages, Moringa Technology Industries (Pty) Ltd, Sleek Foods, Maungo Craft and Divine Morula.
In 2019 seven companies which were enrolled in the Botswana Exporter Development Programme were capacitated with attaining BOBS ISO 9001: 2015 certification. Three (3) companies successfully attained BOBS ISO 9001:2015 certification. These were Lithoflex (Pty) Ltd, General Packaging Industries and Power Engineering.
BITC’s annual flagship exhibition, Global Expo Botswana (GEB) to create opportunities for trade and strategic synergies between local and international companies. The Global Expo Botswana) is a premier business to business exposition that attracts FDI, expansion of domestic investment, promotion of exports of locally produced goods and services and promotion of trade between Botswana and other countries.
The portal also provides information on; measures, legal documents, and forms and procedures needed by Botswana companies that intend on doing business abroad. BITC continues to assist both potential and existing local manufacturing and service entities to realise their export ambitions. This assistance is pursued through the ambit of the Botswana Exporter Development Programme (BEDP) and the Trade Promotion Programme.
BEDP was revised in 2020 in partnership with the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) with a vision to developing a diversified export-based economy. The programme focuses mostly on capacitating companies to reach export readiness status.
Prices for goods and services in this country continue to increase, with the latest figures from Statistics Botswana showing that in May 2022, inflation rate rose to 11.9 percent from 9.6 percent recorded in April 2022.
According to Statistics Botswana update released this week, the largest upward contributions to the annual inflation rate in May 2022 came from increase in the cost of transport (7.2 percent), housing, water, electricity, gas & other Fuels (1.4 percent), food & non-alcoholic beverages (1.1 percent) and miscellaneous goods & services (0.8 percent).
With regard to regional inflation rates between April and May 2022, the Rural Villages inflation rate went up by 2.5 percentage points, from 9.6 percent in April to 12.1 percent in May 2022, according to the government owned statistics entity.
In the monthly update the entity stated that the Urban Villages inflation rate stood at 11.8 percent in May 2022, a rise of 2.4 percentage points from the April rate of 9.4 percent, whereas the Cities & Towns inflation rate recorded an increase of 1.9 percentage points, from 9.9 percent in April to 11.8 percent in May.
Commenting on the national Consumer Price Index, the entity stated that it went up by 2.6 percent, from 120.1 in April to 123.2 in May 2022. Statisticians from the entity noted that the transport group index registered an increase of 7.3 percent, from 134.5 in April to 144.2 in May, mainly due to the rise in retail pump prices for petrol and diesel by P1.54 and P2.74 per litre respectively, which effected on the 13th of May 2022.
The food & non-alcoholic beverages group index rose by 2.6 percent, from 118.6 in April 2022 to 121.6 in May 2022 and this came as a result of increase in prices of oils & fats, vegetables, bread & cereal, mineral waters, soft drinks, fruits & vegetables juices, fish (Fresh, Chilled & Frozen) and meat (Fresh, Chilled & Frozen), according to the Statisticians.
The Statisticians said the furnishing, household equipment & routine maintenance group index rose by 1.0 percent, from 111.6 in April 2022 to 112.7 in May 2022 and this was attributed to a general increase in prices of household appliances, glassware, tableware & household utensils and goods & services for household maintenance.
The prices for clothing & footwear group index moved from 109.4 to 110.4, registering a rise of 0.9 percent during the period under review. Bank of Botswana has projected higher inflation in the short term, associated with the likelihood of further increases in domestic fuel prices in response to persistent high international oil prices and added that the possible increase in public service salaries could add also upward pressure to inflation in this country.