Botswana has been urged to increase its internal borrowings and further develop its domestic capital market to prepare for rainy days. This was reiterated at the Bond Market Conference hosted by Botswana Bond Market Association in Gaborone recently.
Giving key note address at the conference Dr. Michael Atingi-Ego, Director of Macroeconomic & Financial Management Institute of Eastern & Southern Africa said Botswana has strong macroeconomic environment attributed by low inflation and strong fiscal balances and thus the country should have a strong capital market. Dr Ego noted that the country however currently has a number of issues contributing to lack of liquidity in secondary market. “Botswana needs to develop capital market for future needs when government surpluses decline,” he said.
Ego told the audience that Botswana needs clearly defined and prioritized debt management objectives that balance between sovereign debt, running down banking system balances and bond market development. He noted that developing Secondary markets and corporate bond market was a cumbersome process by nature, that comprised of various challenges and requires planning and various stakeholder commitment to achieve. “Improving liquidity is key and it requires enhancing market infrastructure through legal and regulatory framework, clearing and settlement system,” he said.
He highlighted that capital market development requires proper information dissemination mechanisms to facilitate trading and protect investor interests. “If you are to improve liquidity in the market you will also need coordinated stakeholder approach to identify country specific impediments to reform sequence for bond market development, legal, regulatory, accounting and tax issues,” said Dr Ego.
According to speakers at the conference corporate bond market development depends on company financing patterns and requires well developed yield curve to facilitate the pricing of corporate bonds. Botswana was also advised to work with International Organizations to develop LCBM –CwA, WB and Joint Capital Market Development for country specific intervention on developing liquid, diverse and long-term financing.
African Development Bank was noted as a key stakeholder that Botswana could engage to promote bond market data transparency. The Macroeconomic & Financial Management Institute of Eastern & Southern Africa (MEFMI) Director offered assistance in the areas of organizational framework, debt data management and domestic debt management.
Evolution of Botswana’s Capital Market
Botswana has been internationally recognized among the fastest growing economies in the world. Botswana’s development has been particularly shown through the exponential growth in the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in the decades following independence, infrastructure development, improved standards of living, and reduction in poverty, and impressive socio-economic performance ratings by multiple international organizations, among other indicators.
While the mining sector has for a long time remained the back bone of the economy, the country has made significant strides in developing its financial services sector and increasing the sector’s contribution to GDP. In the same token, the local capital markets have registered impressive growth over the years and have been an important avenue for capitalizing broad-based economic growth, economic empowerment as well as economic diversification.
According to the research undertaken and published by the Botswana Stock Exchange, and Botswana Bond Market Association the development of the bond market in Botswana Commenced in 1997 with the issuance of a BWP 50 million bond by Botswana Development Corporation (BDC). By 1999, three more bonds were floated on the BSE and these were floated by Botswana Telecommunications Corporation (BTC), Investec South Africa, and Botswana Building Society (BBS).
During these years and leading to 2003 there was no risk-free yield curve, the only reference points were the Bank of Botswana Certificate (BoBC) rate, the Bank rate and the Prime rate. In an effort to increase the competitiveness and lure lenders away from investing in BoBCs on a recurring basis, most bonds at that time were priced with reference to the BoBC rate. Furthermore BSE says there seemed to be no incentive for neither the public sector nor the private sector to consistently issue debt instruments due to consecutive years of fiscal surplus.
The private sector could conveniently borrow needed funds from commercial banks and as a result, the growth of the bond market was slow in the early stages of its establishment. The noticeable growth in the size of the bond market in 2003 was largely attributable to the issuance of the first 3 Government bonds (BW001, BW002 and BW003) under a Note Issuance Program which ran until 2008. The BW001, BW002 and BW003 were 2-year, 5-year and 12-year bonds of BWP 750 million, BWP 850 million and BWP 900 million respectively.
The issuance of these bonds was a momentous step as it triggered a host of other issuances by parastatals, banks and larger corporate bodies. This also broadened the diversity of issuances from the private sector by retail, financial services, and property and banking entities.
On the larger Africa space experts at the conference noted that yield curves in African capital markets do not go beyond 5 years for most countries. Albin Kakou, Executive at the African Development Bank noted that there are no Government benchmark-basis for pricing corporate bonds in most African countries. “African Capital Markets are facing the challenge of shallow and illiquid markets which are made of undeveloped market Infrastructure (CSD’s) as well as irregular benchmark auctions and undiversified investor base,” he said.
Mr Kakou advised that primary dealer’s frameworks be revised. The African based lender says the continent needs to develop a comprehensive data base to provide updated, reliable and complete information on African domestic bond markets. According to Albin Kakou this would help in improving the availability and transparency of African fixed income markets-related data as well as assisting in reconciling and standardizing data produced by several institutions, using different concepts and methods and enhancing the quality of financial statistics on the continent.
Botswana currently has 40 constituent bonds, of which 33 are corporate bonds with 24 fixed being rate bonds. Government has 7 bonds on issue. Total nominal amount of Bonds on issue adds up to over P15 billion. To further develop Botswana‘s capital market this week Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE) CEO, Mr. Thapelo Tsheole, was part of a distinguished panel discussion that deliberated on, 'Building Strong Capital Markets: Focus on Good Governance and Transparency' at the Bloomberg Emerging & Frontier Forum 2019 held at the new Bloomberg Headquarters in London earlier today.
Hosted by multi billionaire and one of the world wealthiest businessman Michael Bloomberg in collaboration with Aberdeen Standard Investments, Fitch Ratings and the Institute of International Finance. This flagship event was able to bring together heads of state, ministers, central bank governors and top executives to share their insights into the opportunities, risks, and growth potential of emerging and frontier markets.
Botswana mining production picked up significantly in the last quarter of 2021 when compared to the same quarter in 2020 albeit a decline when mirrored against the preceding quarter; Q3 2022, Statistics Botswana revealed in the latest Index of Mining production report released this week.
The Index of Mining Production stood at 82.0 during the fourth quarter of 2021, showing a year-on-year increase of 28.1 percent from 64.0 recorded during the fourth quarter of 2020. Comparison on a quarter on-quarter basis shows a decrease of 19.6 percent from the index of 101.9 realised during the third quarter of 2021.
The main contributor to the year-on-year increase in mining production came from Diamonds, the country‘s flagship export commodity contributed 23.1 percentage points. Gold and Soda Ash were the only negative contributors to mining production, at negative 0.8 and negative 0.1 of a percentage point respectively.
On annual basis, the total index of mining production stood at 86.0, showing an increase of 37.0 percent in 2021 when compared to 62.8 registered in 2020. The 37.0 percent increase in annual mining production followed a decrease of 28.1 percent in 2020 and a decrease of 3.9 in 2019.
Although the total index of mining production increased in some parts of the period 2011 to 2021, experts at Statistics Botswana have observed and noted that it has been decreasing at an average annual rate of 0.7 percent during the last ten (10) years.
The increase in the total mining production in 2021 was mainly due to the growth realized in diamond production which contributed 33.1 percentage points to the total mining production growth. Diamond production increased by 24.2 percent (1, 038 thousand carats) from 4, 290 thousand carats during the fourth quarter of 2020 to 5, 329 thousand carats during the same quarter of 2021.
The increase was a result of intensified production strategy aligned with stronger trading conditions. The quarter-on-quarter analysis shows that production registered a decrease of 18.0 percent (1,172 thousand carats) during the fourth quarter of 2021 compared with 6, 500 thousand carats during the third quarter of 2021.
Copper in Concentrates production commenced during the third quarter of 2021 following 6 years of non-production since closure of BCL, Mowana and Boseto Mine in Toteng. The Toteng Mine has since returned to production under new ownership Khoemacau Copper Mining and is currently the only copper producing operation.
Mowana Mine has also been reborn under new ownership and it bears the nomenclature Kopano Copper Mine, production is expected to start soon. Some assets of BCL have been taken up Premium Nickel Resources, a subsidiary of Canadian North America Nickel.
During the fourth quarter of 2021, an amount of 4, 225 tonnes of Copper in Concentrates was produced. The quarter-on-quarter analysis shows that production decreased by 43.8 percent (3,292 tonnes) during the fourth quarter of 2021 compared with 7, 517 tonnes produced during the third quarter of 2021.
Gold production decreased by 49.1 percent (109 kilograms) during the fourth quarter of 2021, from 222 kilograms during the same quarter of the previous year to 113 kilograms during the period under review. Similarly, the quarter-on-quarter analysis reflects a decrease of 35.9 percent (63 kilograms) from 176 kilograms in the preceding quarter to 113 kilograms during the fourth quarter of 2021. The decrease was a result of the deteriorating lifespan of the mine arising from resource depletion.
Soda Ash production decreased by 4.4 percent (3, 116 tonnes) from 70, 159 tonnes during the fourth quarter of 2020 to 67, 043 tonnes produced during the period under review. On the other hand, quarter-on-quarter analysis shows that production went up by 2.8 percent (1, 848 tonnes) during the period under review, from 65, 195 tonnes during the previous quarter.
Salt production went up by 27.9 percent (31, 385 tonnes) to 143, 751 tonnes during the fourth quarter of 2021, from 112, 366 tonnes during the same quarter of the previous year. On the other hand, quarter-on-quarter analysis shows that salt production registered a decrease of 15.4 percent (26, 075 tonnes) compared with 169, 826 tonnes during the third quarter of 2021.
Silver production commenced during the third quarter of 2021 following 6 years of non-production as the associated mine was undergoing liquidation. During the fourth quarter of 2021, 3, 626 tonnes of silver were produced.
The quarter-on-quarter analysis shows that production decreased by 46.3 percent (3,131 tonnes) during the fourth quarter of 2021 compared with 6, 757 kg produced during the third quarter of 2021. Although the production is still at infancy, it is worthy to note that the mine is under new management following liquidation in 2015.
Coal production increased by 9.3 percent (40, 099 tonnes), from 429, 382 tonnes during the fourth quarter of 2020, to 469, 481 tonnes in the current quarter. The increase came as a result of the efforts made to meet increased demand from both domestic and international markets, particularly that new markets have been identified.
On the other hand, quarter-on-quarter comparison shows that coal production decreased by 14.5 percent (79, 746 tonnes) compared with 549, 227 tonnes during the third quarter of the current year. Copper-Nickel-Cobalt Matte recorded zero production during the period under review. The affected mines are still under liquidation.
Nearly 10 years and over P10 billion later, Morupule B – a 600 Megawatt coal fired power plant that was envisaged to end Botswana ‘s national power crises still can’t deliver to full capacity, forcing the country to pay over P2 billion annually in importation of power from surrounding producer nations.
The latest quarterly report from Statistics Botswana, reviewing the country’s power generation for the fourth quarter of 2021 has written off the progress made during the third quarter, reporting a quarter-on-quarter decrease of 18.9 percent, from an Index of Electricity Generation (IEG) of 137.7 during the third quarter of 2021 to 111.7, giving a clear reflection that the country takes 2 steps forward and 3 steps backward as far as local power generation is concerned.
In the third quarter of 2021, electricity generation had picked up, with a 14.6 percent points jump on IEG, from the Index of 120.2 during the second quarter of 2021. In physical terms, local electricity generation had increased by 14.6 percent (73,723 MWH), from 505,313 MWH during the second quarter of 2021.Statistics Botswana had credited the increase to improved performance of Morupule A and B power stations.
However in a setback during the last quarter of 2021 production of electricity locally took a downturn, both on quarterly and year-on-year basis, mainly due operational challenges at Morupule B. A year-on-year analysis shows a decrease of 9.3 percent in IEG, compared to 123.1 recorded during the corresponding quarter in 2020.
The physical volume of electricity generated decreased by 9.3 percent (48,278 MWH), from 517,627 MWH during the fourth quarter of 2020 to 469,349 MWH during the current quarter.
The quarter-on-quarter perspective shows that local electricity generation decreased by 18.9 percent (109,686 MWH), from 579,036 MWH during the third quarter of 2021 to 469,349 MWH during the period under review. “This decrease was largely due to operational challenges at Morupule B power plant.” Said Statistics Botswana
A decrease in local generation means increase in importation, during the fourth quarter of 2021, the physical volume of imported electricity increased by 16.7 percent (77,716 MWH), from 465,701 MWH during the fourth quarter of 2020 to 543,417 MWH during the quarter under review.
Compared to the previous quarter, electricity imported during the fourth quarter of 2021 increased by 28.0 percent (118,714 MWH), from 424,703 MWH during the third quarter of 2021 to 543,417 MWH.
Botswana imported 53.7 percent of total electricity distributed during the fourth quarter of 2021. Eskom, South Africa’s state-owned power generation outfit was as usual the main source of imported electricity at 40.6 percent of total electricity imports.
The Zambia Electricity Supply Corporation Limited (ZESCO) accounted for 22.0 percent, while the remaining 17.0, 15.0, 4.0 and 1.4 percent were sourced from Electricidade De Mozambique (EDM), Southern African Power Pool (SAPP), Cross-border electricity markets and Nampower, respectively.
Cross-border electricity markets is a Statistics Botswana nomenclature referring to towns and villages along the border which are supplied with electricity directly from neighbouring countries such as Namibia and Zambia.
In terms of distribution year-on-year analysis shows that the amount of distributed electricity increased by 3.0 percent (29,438 MHW), from 983,328 MWH during the fourth quarter of 2020 to 1,012,766 MWH during the current quarter.
The quarter-on-quarter comparison of distributed electricity shows an increase of 0.9 percent (9,028 MWH), from 1,003,738 MWH during the third quarter of 2021 to 1,012,766 MWH during the review quarter.
Electricity generated locally contributed 46.3 percent to electricity distributed during the fourth quarter of 2021, compared to a contribution of 52.6 percent during the same quarter in 2020, a decrease of 6.3 percentage points.
The quarter-on-quarter comparison shows that the contribution of electricity generated to electricity distributed decreased by 11.4 percentage points compared to the 57.7 percent.
MORUPULE B CHALLENGES
The Morupule B project was adopted as the least cost solution to guarantee electricity supply, self-sufficiency and address the challenges in the energy sector of Botswana. The plant comprises of 4 units with capacity of 150 megawatt each, totalling 600 megawatt, all coal fired, together with associated transmission infrastructure.
Located adjacent to the existing 132 megawatt Morupule A plant, Morupule B was constructed at over P10 billion, funded by debt finance from the African Development Bank, and was supposed to have been completed and fully commissioned in 2013, however almost 10 years later the multibillion-pula plant is still not fully operational, instead cost overruns are reported at over P4 billion still counting.
In a media briefing early this year Minister of Minerals & Energy Lefoko Moagi said construction of the plant was budgeted for P9 billion, but the total cost of construction ended up ballooning to over P12 billion. He explained that out of 4 units only 2 were working being Unit 2 and Unit 3, producing 80 megawatt and 150 megawatt respectively.
He said Unit 1 was currently at forced outage because of total failure while Unit 4 was under commissioning following completion of remedial works. “What we are doing in Morupule B is that we are changing the heat exchangers, and we have requested from the initial designers to furnish us with a new design of heat exchangers, technologically advanced with proper output configurations”.
Minister Moagi explained that the units will be restarted gradually until the plant is fully operational at 100 percent output levels. Remedial works were delayed by COVID -19 travel restrictions, and the plant will now be fully operational in 2024.
According to Minister Moagi, Botswana will not incure any cost, remedial cost will be fully taken care of by contractor. “As for us, we had budgeted for P45 million, as incidental costs, because our Engineers will be travelling to Morupule, we will be engaging experts to assess the work for us etc.”
In terms of efforts toward clean energy Minister Moagi said Morupule A wad already implementing clean coal technologies, fuel gas desulphurisation technique in place. “At Morupule B the new heat exchangers that we are installing will have reduced gas emissions,” he said.
De Beers Group is deploying the Tracr™ blockchain platform at scale for its diamond production. Tracr™ is the world’s only distributed diamond blockchain that starts at the source and provides tamper-proof source assurance at scale, enabling Sightholders to provide an immutable record of a diamond’s provenance, and empowering jewellery retailers to have confidence in the origin of the diamonds they purchase.
With more end clients wanting to know the source of the products they buy, the deep meaning associated with a diamond purchase requires a technological step-change to meet their expectations. The introduction of Tracr™ at scale delivers immutable information on the source of De Beers’ diamonds across the value chain and makes source assurance for 100% of De Beers’ production possible.
The Tracr™ platform combines distributed ledger technology with advanced data security and privacy, ensuring that participants control the use of and access to their own data. Each participant on Tracr™ has their own distributed version of the platform, meaning that their data can only be shared with their permission, and only they choose who can access their information.
The advanced privacy technologies used by Tracr™ reinforce data security on the platform. The immutable nature of each transaction on the platform ensures that the data cannot be tampered with when the diamond progresses through the value chain.
The decentralised nature of the platform ensures its speed and scalability, with the ability to register one million diamonds a week onto the platform. With centralised platforms, dealing with large volumes of data can cause bottlenecks, but the decentralised model used by Tracr™ avoids such issues and enables rapid scaling.
The scalability, speed and security of Tracr™ are combined into an intuitive user experience to support ease of use for platform participants. First launched in an R&D phase in 2018 and named by Forbes as one of the world’s 50 leading blockchain solutions in both 2020 and in 2022, De Beers has already registered one quarter of its production by value on Tracr™ in the first three Sights of the year in preparation for this first scale release.
Bruce Cleaver, CEO, De Beers Group, said: “De Beers discovers diamonds with our partners in Botswana, Canada, Namibia and South Africa and, with our long-term investment in Tracr™, we are proud to join with our Sightholders to provide the industry with immutable diamond source assurance at scale.
Tracr™, which will enable the provision of provenance information from source to Sightholder to store on a secure blockchain, will underpin confidence in natural diamonds and represents the first step in a technological transformation that will enhance standards and raise expectations of what we are capable of providing to our end clients.”
Lefoko Moagi, Minister of Minerals and Energy, Government of Botswana said: “The introduction of this advanced provenance technology is extremely exciting and we are very pleased as a large diamond producing country, and shareholder in De Beers, to be a part of this development. Confidence in diamond origin is extremely important and we look forward to seeing the roll out of this new programme delivering new benefits to the diamond industry and giving more assurance to consumers.”
The Tracr™ platform brings together a range of leading technologies – including blockchain, artificial intelligence, the Internet of Things and advanced security and privacy technologies – to support the identification of a diamond’s journey through the value chain.
De Beers’ provenance claims have been certified by the Responsible Jewellery Council and trust in the De Beers source of diamonds is also assured by the business’s Pipeline Integrity programme which involves annual third-party verification visits of participants by independent auditors.