Botswana Movement for Democracy’s court application, in which they were challenging their ejection from the Umbrella for Democratic Change (UDC), was this week dismissed with costs, a decision taken unanimously by a panel of three judges.
The much anticipated court verdict was dramatically delayed after the court staff printed the wrong version of judgment. The High Court upheld BMD’s expulsion by UDC before recognizing Botswana Congress Party (BCP), as a full member of the umbrella project. Since its acceptance in the UDC, BMD has never been at peace with BCP inclusion claiming that they (BCP), were out to grab their (BMD) constituencies and this was part of the politically charged court case.
The BMD argued that the UDC decisively ignored the constitution and failed to follow the right structures when expelling it. When countering the BMD argument, UDC said BMD was irrelevant by saying its expulsion was unconstitutional because the same constitution they interpreted clearly indicates that the constitution allows for restricting of the National Executive Committee (NEC) body.
When passing a judgment, the Gaborone High Court quashed the BMD claim saying the party which is led by veteran lawyer Sidney Pilane, failed to produce a legal and credible case to convince the courts. A vividly jubilant UDC president Duma Boko, welcomed the judgment stating that, “when I speak about this matter I speak with potency and authority. I have fought this battle and I have all the scars of this battle!”
However, for Pilane it is not over yet as he is not conceding to a defeat by UDC. “I think we will file an appeal application tomorrow (Friday),” Pilane told journalists after the much anticipated judgment. Last month Pilane lost another case involving the UDC, in which he wanted the party president Boko, to be struck from the voters’ roll because he had not registered at his residential place. In this case, the UDC was represented by South African senior counsel Kennedy Paul and senior counsel, public speaker, author and political activist, Tembeka Ngcukaitobi. BMD and its leader Pilane, on the other hand were represented by South African senior counsel Alexandra John Freund, as they battled it out in court.
BMD SUBMISSION BY SC ALEXANDRA FREUND
In their heads of submission, Freund said in expelling the BMD, the UDC decisively ignored the constitution and failed to follow the right structures. He stressed that the body which purported to suspend and expel the BMD from UDC styled itself as the NEC. The South African attorney further said that the structural body was not part of the NEC and had no power to suspend or expel the BMD from UDC.
Freud, also submitted that the body which purported to take the offending decisions has not been elected by UDC constitutional structures, therefore it is not constituted. “The only entities of the UDC which could have authority under the constitution, in justifiable circumstances, to suspend or expel a member of the UDC are its NEC, which it made provisions for and constituted in terms of the UDC registered.” He therefore emphasized that the suspension and expulsion decisions were not taken by the Umbrella Negotiating Team (UNT), since it has not operated or existed since August 2012.
The South African senior counsel further narrated and submitted to the court, that prior to taking the decision to suspend and expel BMD, the Presidents and Secretary Generals of the BMD and BPP, were not present and did not have prior notice of the meeting at which these decisions were taken.
“Similarly, neither the BMD President and Secretary General and none of the 5 Conveners of the Negotiation Process participated in the body which purported to be the NEC and in the taking of the impugned decisions, nor did any of them have notice of the offending meetings; both of which invalidated the meetings and the decisions there made.”
Freud said the reasons given for the decisions to suspend and expel the BMD from the UDC, are ostensible and false, the true reason being; an unlawful conspiracy by the BCP and BNF to take the 14 constituencies allocated by the UDC to the BMD in which the party (BMD), will present its members as UDC parliamentary candidates in the 2019 general elections.
Freund then questioned UDC constitutional affairs. “The UDC has not, since its inception, held an elective congress and has never given notice of an intention to hold such a national congress as is required by Article 188.8.131.52 of the UDC registered Constitution,” he said.
UDC’S COUNTER ATTACK BY SC KENNEDY PAUL AND THEMBEKA NGCUKAITOBI
The UDC lawyers evidently held the BMD case in derision. Paul, told the court that it has no interest in participating in the expulsion of the BMD. “What we have here is a political situation, and with all due respect, it is unrealistic to seek the court to interfere in political matters,” he said. Paul said that BMD’s submission that the UDC failed to abide by the constitution and allowed the wrong structural bodies to make a decision in expelling the BMD, was irrelevant as the same constitution they interpreted clearly indicates that the constitution allows for restricting of the NEC body.
Adding to Paul’s arguments, Ngcukaitobi pointed out to the court that the applicant failed to establish a case on the basis of its suspension and that UDC has before expelling the BMD used the right body, structures and processes. “The political party should be allowed to run its course, this court has no interest in participating in the expulsion of the BMD. Therefore, we move that this application be dismissed and with costs,” Ngcukaitobi said.
Ngcukaitobi also stressed that indeed all the constituents’ members were present when taking the decision to suspend and expel the BMD. He emphasized that the right decision was taken by the right structures and the right procedure was followed. “The UDC was dealing with a BMD that has split. There has been an internal squabble in the BMD. There was chaos inside the BMD, the BMD has always provoked other members, and its leader is provocative,” said Ngcukaitobi.
The South African young lawyer further emphasized that the process followed indicates that whatever decision was taken, shows that it was a dialogue since 2017, and there was no bias. “On the 11th of November 2017, Pilane was reprimanded in the internal meeting for making toxic pronouncements, but on the 11th of October last year, he denied everything. This was after a meeting on the 18th of September, in which the UDC condemned and blamed their Moshupa-Manyana by-election loss on BMD. Chaos within the BMD is spilling over to UDC, hence the need to take a decision,” Ngcukaitobi reminded the court.
In conclusion, Ngcukaitobi casted doubt on Pilane working together again with UDC, saying political alliance should be based on trust. He insisted that: “What has been politically broken cannot be legally fixed. We have a pointless application here. What we have here is the highest form of breakdown between these two parties. Dismiss the case and ask them to pay the costs.”
As the media industry comes full circle with sexual harassment policies in the workplace, media houses have been urged to ensure that this process cuts a wide swath so as to broaden the buy in.
Media organizations have begun to reassess and revise their sexual harassment policies as WIN continues to heighten a campaign against sexual harassment in the workplace. All the while a handful of organizations are either at drafting or implementation level of the policy.
To help media organizations crack down on sexual harassment, WAN-IFRA Women In News (WIN) held its 15th Round Table Meeting (Virtual) on 5th November, 2020 aimed at furthering sensitisation on the subject.
Media executives from Sub-Saharan Africa who attended the Roundtable meeting were motivated to climb on the bandwagon to address sexual harassment in the workplace.
A renowned expert in human resource concepts, Carin Anderson, shared on managing and preventing sexual harassment in news organisations. Anderson explored on essential tools that could assist organisations to navigate sexual harassment complaints effectively.
Anderson cautioned media executives against condoning a culture of Sexual Harassment. Linking sexual harassment to the current situation where COVID-19 has put many media houses in the red, Anderson cautioned it could negatively affect productivity.
She said staff could be forced to exit organisations, a development that will ultimately affect the financial performance of the business.
By hook or crook, organisations need to draft and implement comprehensive sexual harassment policies that are comprehensible to staff. According to Anderson, media executives must ensure of policies that have a prevention and cure approach while at the same time avoiding reactionary approaches.
She is of the view that a thorough sexual harassment policy could protect brands, would-be victims and the organisation untainted culture.
While the debate on sexual harassment has been dominated by fits and starts, of late progress has been by leaps and bounds. Anderson opined that conducting anonymous surveys continues to determine the culture of an organization hence helps create conducive working conditions for employees.
She observed that such surveys are very important because everyone is given a chance to air their views or concerns. In doing so, employees will feel comfortable and free to share their experiences.
Anderson further said anonymous surveys can also help to depict any unwanted behaviours in an organisation. Such surveys promote the culture of calling a spade a spade. She advised all media partners present at the meeting to create a safe and clean environment for their employees than to wait for the symptoms of sexual harassment to manifest.
“Organisations need to implement the policy and create more awareness through training. In order to create more awareness organisations need to come up with code of conduct and set procedures that promote zero tolerance for sexual harassment,” she said.
WIN executive Director, Melane Walker denoted that sexual harassment happens everywhere; and it is very important to have an internal policy that deals with it. Having a written internal policy has helped WIN to significantly navigate sexual harassment quandary, she said.
All participants were encouraged to have a Sexual Harassment policy and to share it with everyone in the organisation.
The United Nation’s UNiTE campaign has marked the beginning of 16 days of activism against Gender-based Violence which will end in December 10 2020, under the global theme, “Orange the world: Fund, Respond, Prevent, Collect!”
The UN Secretary-General’s UNiTE by 2030 to End Violence against Women campaign (UNiTE campaign), managed by UN Women — is a multi-year effort aimed at preventing and eliminating violence against women and girls around the world.
The UN Women’s generation equality campaign emphasises the call for global action to bridge funding gaps, ensure essential services for survivors of violence during the COVID-19 crisis, focus on prevention, and collection of data that can improve life-saving services for women and girls.
Furthermore, the UN Secretary General’s report maintains that this year is like no other. Even before Covid-19 hit, violence against women and girls had reached pandemic proportions.
Globally, according to United Nations, 243 million women and girls were abused by an intimate partner in the past year.
Meanwhile, less than 40 percent of women who experience violence report it or seek help.
Evidently they suggest that as countries implemented lockdown measures to stop the spread of the coronavirus, violence against women, especially domestic violence, intensified- in some countries, calls to helplines have increased five-fold.
“In others, formal reports of domestic violence have decreased as survivors find it harder to seek help and access support through the regular channels. School closures and economic strains left women and girls poorer, out of school and out of jobs, and more vulnerable to exploitation, abused, forced marriage, and harassment,” said the UN.
According to the UN, in April 2020 as the pandemic spread across the world, the UN Secretary-General called for “peace at home”, and 146 member states responded with their strong statement of commitment.
“In recent months 135 countries have strengthened actions and resources to address violence against women as part of the response to Covid-19. Yet, much more is needed,” said the report.
Moreover, they submit that as today, although the voices of activists and survivors have reached a crescendo that cannot be silenced or ignored, ending violence against women will require more investment, leadership and action.
“It cannot be sidelined; it must be part of every country’s national response, especially during the unfolding COVID-19 crisis,” contended the UN report.
For the 16 Days of Activism, UN Women handed over the mic to survivors, activists and UN partners on the ground, to tell the story of what happened after COVID-19 hit.
According to Dubravka Šimonovic, special rapporteur on violence against women, there is urgent need to end pandemic of femicide and violence against women.
Ahead of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, she emphasizes that as the world grapples with the devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and its negative impact on women, a pandemic of femicide and gender-based violence against womenis taking the livesof women and girls everywhere.
Therefore, she is calling on all States and relevant stakeholders worldwide to take urgent steps to prevent the pandemic of femicide or gender related killings of women, and gender-based violence against women, through the establishment of national multidisciplinary prevention bodies or femicide watches/observatories on violence against women.
These bodies should be mandated to 1) collect comparable and disaggregated data on femicide or gender-related killings of women; 2) conduct an analysis of femicide cases to determine shortcomings, and recommend measures for the prevention of such cases, and 3) ensure that femicide victims are not forgotten by holding days of remembrance.
“Data this mandate has collected since 2015 through my Femicide Watch initiative corroborates the data available from the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, and indicates that among the victims of all intentional killings involving intimate partners, more than 80% of victims are women. Many of these femicides are preventable. Since 2015, a growing number of States have either established femicide watches or observatories, and in an increasing number of countries, it is the independent human rights institutions, civil society organizations, women’s groups and/or academic institutions that have established femicide watches or observatories,” she argued.
GBV in Botswana
UNFDP (United Nations Population Fund) Botswana cites that, locally over 67 percent of women have experienced abuse, which is over double the global average.
“Gender-based violence undermines the health, dignity, security and autonomy of its victims, yet it remains shrouded in a culture of silence and normalization. Victims of violence, the majority of which are women and girls, can suffer sexual and reproductive health consequences, including forced and unwanted pregnancies, sexually transmitted infections including HIV, and even death,” indicated UNFDP
In his 2020 State of the Nation Address (SONA) he delivered on Monday 9th November at the Gaborone International Convention Centre (GICC), President Mokgweetsi Masisi said government is concerned about the snowballing of GBV incidences, saying, they have prioritized drafting of a Sexual Offenders Bill to be tabled during the sitting of the 12th Parliament.
“The Bill will establish a Sex Offenders’ Registry to record and publicise names and particulars of all persons convicted of sexual offences. To date twelve districts have set up the District Gender Committees in Chobe, Kweneng, Kgatleng, Kgalagadi, Maun, Serowe, Selibe-Phikwe, North East, Bobirwa Sub District, Mabutsane Sub District, Goodhope Sub District as well as Mahalapye Sub District. These committees will promote gender equality and women’s empowerment, and also address gender based violence,” Masisi said.
The President highlighted that the Botswana Police Service, which has been dealing a lot with GBV cases has taken swift action and introduced a Toll-Free number for reports on gender based violence. He further indicated that the Police will establish a Gender and Child Protection Unit
An international report complied in South Africa dubbed ‘Legal Gender Recognition in Botswana’ says that the transgender and gender non-conforming people in Botswana live a miserable life. The community experiences higher levels of discrimination, violence and ill health.
In this report, it has been indicated that this is because their gender identity, which does not conform to narrowly define societal norms, renders them more vulnerable. Gender identity is a social determinant of health, which means that it is a factor that influences people’s health via their social context, their communities and their experiences of social exclusion. The Ministry of Health and Wellness has recognized this, and transgender people are considered a vulnerable population under the Botswana Second National Strategic Framework for HIV and AIDS 2010-2017.
In a recent study that shed light on the lived experiences of transgender and gender non-conforming people in Botswana, transgender persons often experience discrimination because of their gender identity and expression. The study was conducted by the University of Cape Town, LEGABIBO, BONELA, as well as Rainbow Identity Association and approved by the Health Ministry as well as the University of Botswana.
Of the 77 transgender and gender non-conforming people who participated in the study, less than half were employed. Two thirds, which is approximately 67% said that they did not have sufficient funds to cover their everyday needs. Two in five had hidden health concerns from their healthcare provider because they were afraid to disclose their gender identity.
More than half said that because of their gender identity, they had been treated disrespectfully at a healthcare facility (55%), almost half (46%) said they had been insulted at a healthcare facility, and one quarter (25%) had been denied healthcare because of their gender identity.
At the same time, the ‘Are we doing right’ study suggests that transgender and non-conforming people might be at higher risks of experiencing violence and mental ill-health, compared to the general population. More than half had experienced verbal embarrassment because of their gender identity, 48% had experienced physical violence and more than one third (38%) had experienced sexual violence.
The study showed that mental health concerns were high among transgender and gender non-conforming people in Botswana. Half of the transgender and gender non-conforming study participants (53%) showed signs of depression. Between one in four and one in six showed signs of moderate or severe anxiety (22% among transgender women, 24% among transgender men and 17% among gender non-conforming people).
Further, the study revealed that many had attempted suicide: one in three transgender women (32%), more than one in three transgender men (35%) and three in five gender non-conforming people (61%).
International research, as well as research from Botswana, suggests that not being able to change one’s gender marker has a negative impact on access to healthcare and mental health and wellbeing. The study further showed that one in four transgender people in Botswana (25%) had been denied access to healthcare. This is, at least in part, linked to not being able to change one’s gender marker in the identity documents, and thus not having an identity document that matches one’s gender identity and gender expression.
In its Assessment of Legal and Regulatory Framework for HIV, AIDS and Tuberculosis, the Health Ministry noted that “transgender persons in Botswana are unable to access identity documents that reflect their gender identity, which is a barrier to health services, including in the context of HIV. In one documented case, a transwoman’s identity card did not reflect her gender identity- her identity card photo indicated she was ‘male’. When she presented her identity card at a health facility, a health worker called the police who took her into custody.”
The necessity of a correct national identity document goes beyond healthcare. The High Court of Botswana explains that “the national identity document plays a pivotal role in every Motswana’s daily life, as it links him or her with any service they require from various institutions. Most activities in the country require every Motswana to produce their identity document, for identification purposes of receiving services.”
According to the Legal Gender Recognition in Botswana report, this effectively means that transgender, whose gender identity and expression is likely to be different from the sex assigned to them at birth and from what is recorded on their identity document, cannot access services without risk of denial or discrimination, or accusations of fraud.
In this context, gays and lesbians advocacy group LEGABIBO has called on government through the Department of Civil and National Registration to urgently implement the High Court rulings on gender marker changes. As stated by the High Court in the ND vs Attorney General of Botswana judgement, identity cards (Omang) play an important role in the life of every Motswana. Refusal and or delay to issue a Motswana with an Omang is denying them to live a complete and full-filing life with dignity and violates their privacy and freedom of expression.
The judgement clarified that persons can change their gender marker as per the National Registrations Act, so changing the gender marker is legally possible. There is no need for a court order. It further said the person’s gender is self-identified, there is no need to consult medical doctors.
LEGABIBO also called on government to develop regulations that specify administrative procedure to change one’s gender marker, and observing self-determination process. Further, the group looks out for government to ensure members of the transgender community are engaged in the development of regulations.
“We call on this Department of Civil and National Registration to ensure that the gender marker change under the National Registration Act is aligned to the Births and Deaths Registry Act to avoid court order.
Meanwhile, a gay man in Lobatse, Moabi Mokenke was recently viciously killed after being sexually violated in the streets of Peleng, shockingly by his neighbourhood folks. The youthful lad, likely to be 29-years old, met his fate on his way home, from the wearisome Di a Bowa taverns situated in the much populated township of Peleng Central.